Happy Fall! Since it is the first day of Fall 2022, it’s time to celebrate with the New Pumpkin Spice Second Slice Sweet & Spicy Eyeshadow Palette! I look forward, every year, to the Too Faced Autumnal Palette. I love anything that even comes close to the scent or taste of Pumpkin Spice! For me, that embodies Fall! This year’s seasonal Pumpkin Pie inspired eyeshadow palette includes the standard amount, 18 warm fall shades, that have matte, shimmer, matte with glitter, and satin finishes. There are some changes from past Pumpkin Palettes and this year’s palette.
You can find the Too Faced Pumpkin Spice Second Slice Sweet & Spicy Eyeshadow Palette at Ulta, Sephora, and on the Too Faced Website. The Pumpkin Spice Second Slice Eyeshadow Palette 18X (0.031 0z./ 0.88g) costs $54. So the price went from $49 to $54. the price went up $5!
The Packaging changed too! The old packaging was a tin box. 
The new packaging is cardboard, with a magnetic closure. One good thing about cardboard packaging is it is recyclable. And that is a good thing! Also, the cardboard palette is slender, not bulky, and easy to stack with other palettes. Yet, what made the previous years special was the tin box! Just sayin’. 
There is still a large mirror underneath the lid. And, on the other side from the mirror are three rows that each have six shades. The shades are buried in a reflective gold background. Also, the palette is supposed to have the scent of pumpkin pie. Unfortunately, I didn’t smell anything, and I really sniffed it. I love the scent of anything pumpkin spice, and I am really disappointed that this didn’t smell like anything!
The formula for the eight matte shades felt buttery, velvety, creamy texture, and the shades were easy to blend. There was one satin shade. They give one swipe color payoff. Next, there are four metallic shades, and four shimmery shades. 
These shades were hit or miss. Some of the shimmery shades were more topper shades, and the metallics were more pigmented. See the shade descriptions. Finally, there was one shade that had a satin finish. And, one shade had a matte with glitter finish. This shade was thin , patchy, hard to work with, and difficult to swatch.
Shades
Row 1 Across (Left to Right)
Whip it Good, Sip, Sip Hooray, Crust Issues, Cutie Pie, Pick of the Patch, More, Please
Whip it Good
Whip It Good, a nude champagne shade, has a shimmering finish with gold and silver shimmers. This is a beautiful shade topper. It has a clear base, and could go over any of the matte shades.
Sip, Sip Hooray
Sip, Sip Hooray, a light beige shade, has a matte finish. Use this light beige shade as a base.
Crust Issues
Crust Issues, a light burnt orange shade, has a matte finish.
Cutie Pie
Cutie Pie, a rust orange shade, has a metallic finish.
Pick of the Patch
Pick of the Patch, a green-gold shade, has a shimmering finish.
More, Please
More, Please, a dark green black shade, with gold, green and silver shimmer, a matte shade with glitter. This shade was patchy, difficult to swatch, difficult to work with, and lackluster.
Row 2 (Middle Row left to right)
Squash It, Everything Nice, Serving Looks, One More Bite, Cinn-Ful and Spice-Tacular
Squash It
Squash It, a bright orange with yellow, gold and orange reflects has a shimmering finish.
Everything Nice
Everything Nice, a warm yellow nude shade, has a matte finish.
Serving Looks
Serving Looks, a terracotta brown shade, has a matte finish.
One More Bite
One More bite, a marigold shade, has a metallic finish.
Cinn-Ful
Cinn-Ful, a copper brown shade, has a metallic finish.
Spice-tacular
Spice-tacular, a rusty red brown shade, has a matte finish.
Row 3 (Bottom Row Across Left to Right)
Toasted, Second Helping, Scary Spiced, Fall Feels, Thankful, and Eyes on the Pies.
Toasted
Toasted, a light tan shade, has a matte finish.
Second Helping
Second Helping, a deep orange shade, has a matte finish.
Scary Spiced
Scary Spiced, a cool purple brown shade, has a matte finish.
Fall Feels
Fall Feels, a plum shade, has a metallic finish.
Thankful
Thankful, a fuchsia pink shade, has a satin finish.
Eyes on the Pies
Eyes on the Pies, a rust red shade, has a matte finish.
Finally, if you are a Too Faced Spiced Pumpkin fan, you are going to purchase this palette. Is it a must? No. It doesn’t have the pumpkin pie scent that was promised. Instead, it didn’t smell like anything but maybe cardboard. Even more, I missed the tin box that the eyeshadows used to come in. Cardboard is definitely more eco-friendly, and that is good, but the tin box is a keepsake item, that collectors would want. The eyeshadow shades are warm, fall shades. Some of the shades performed better than others, which you can see in the swatches. And, let’s not forget the price has gone up, and the palette costs an extra $5!
